Is the Ftc Wrong About Credit Repair?
Credit repair has its share of detractors, and perhaps for good reason. The FTC campaign against credit repair scams makes perfect sense. But for every consumer that has been disappointed by a questionable credit repair scheme, there are so many more that have benefited from the service of a genuine credit repair professional. Is it time for the FTC to acknowledge the good guys in the credit repair industry?
The credit reporting system is not perfect. There is no debate about this. The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) provides the legal process for consumers to correct errors on their credit reports and initiate a credit repair effort if necessary. How common are these errors? How difficult are they to identify and correct?
You may be aware of the often quoted Public Interest Research Group (PIRG) studies which conclude that three-quarters of all credit reports have errors. The Government Accounting Office (GAO) conducted a study of studies on the subject and also identified the severity of the issue. The real need for credit repair arises from the potential economic impact of these errors which translate into higher interest rates and less favorable terms for those affected.
To appreciate the need for credit repair you need only look at the numbers. Each of the three major Credit Reporting Agencies maintains data on approximately two hundred million Americans. Per the Public Interest Research Group studies, about one hundred fifty million Americans have errors on their credit reports. The PIRG studies conclude that although some of the errors will have little or no bearing on the credit classification of the consumer, a full twenty five percent of the errors are likely to result in outright denial of credit.
Twenty five percent represents fifty million people. As large a number as this is, it is only reasonable to extrapolate that there is an even larger group who suffer needless economic hardship from errors without experiencing outright credit denial. Between the two statistics are one hundred million Americans who may be paying premium interest rates as the result of errors; one hundred million Americans who may be paying higher mortgage payments, auto loan payments, and credit card payments. How far does the Fair Credit Reporting Act go to resolve this problem and aid or encourage the credit repair process?
The truth is that the Fair Credit Reporting Act does very little to mitigate the impact of credit reporting issues or support the credit repair process. The average person has difficulty reading a credit report, and beyond the face value of the information on the report lays the vast array of virtually inaccessible legal information that would facilitate their ability to manage the chore of credit repair. This includes the basic guidelines of the Fair Credit Reporting Act itself, reporting period limits, dispute rights, etc., as well as other legislation that may come to bear such as the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act and individual state statutes of limitation.
The complexity of credit repair in and of itself should not be a problem. The tax code is no less difficult and we all manage to get our tax returns done. For that matter, most of us drive automobiles and have no clue about how an internal combustion engine works, much less how to fix one. The real problem is the public perception of the credit repair industry. Imagine if we were regularly persuaded that accountants were unnecessary; how would we get our taxes done? Or if we were told to stay away from auto mechanics; how many of us would be able to repair or maintain our automobiles adequately?
The accuracy of your credit report is important. Your credit score will determine the cost of every dollar you borrow, and its affect will determine the quality of your life. I understand the FTC campaign against bad credit repair operations. And I understand the importance of the media warnings against illegal credit repair schemes. But for all of the good intentions of the FTC, the result of their myopic anti credit repair attitude has been an enormous cost for millions of people that should have been encouraged to seek professional credit repair help.
For all of the bad publicity surrounding credit repair schemes, there are many excellent professional credit repair businesses. The services provided by these credit repair professionals are no less important than services offered by any financial expert and should be sought out by anyone in need of guidance. As important as the FTC warnings against abusive practices may be, it is time for them to acknowledge the good guys that operate in the credit repair field.
Copyright © 2008 Ian Webber. All Content. All Rights Reserved.
Ian Webber is an expert in consumer law and credit repair. Ian is a graduate of the London School of Economics and The University of Chicago where he earned his LLM. Ian consults with one of the leading online credit repair services and contributes regularly to a prominent credit repair blog. Ian is currently based in Florida.
